Departure for New Zealand
On 19 March, Furneaux “haul’d up for New Zealand”. He wrote, “it is my opinion that there is no Streights between New Holland and Van Dieman’s Land, but a very deep bay. I should have stood further to the Northward, but the wind blowing strong at SSE and looking likely to haul round to the Eastward, which would have blown right on the Land, I therefore thought it more prudent to leave the Coast and steer for New Zealand”.
Not everyone in the ship was certain that a strait south of Cape Barren did not exist. Burney wrote on one of his charts, “Suposed Streights or Passage”. Midshipman Richard Hergest thought “Cape Barren... Appeared to be an Island and Formed the North head of the Supposed Streight”.
Gales drove Adventure east across the Tasman Sea on most remaining days in March. On 24 March, Furneaux wrote in his log, “Shipp’d a Sea which stove both Cutters”. He wrote slightly more in his journal. “Ship’d a Sea that stove the large Cutter and washed the small one out of her into the waist”.
Sloop Resolution Alone
After failing to find Adventure, Captain Cook on 10 February “gave over all hopes of joining her till we arrive at New Zealand which I had appointed to Winter at and made sail to the SE”.
On 13 February, Cooper wrote, “Smoak’d the Ship between Desks with Gunpowder... All this afternoon a great number of Penguins about the Ship, which are very difft from those seen on the Coast of Newfoundland, being much smaller & no white Ring about the Neck or Eyes. These spring out of the Water like SkipJacks & has kept way with the Ship. They have also something Red about the head”. The birds he saw in Newfoundland in 1766-1770 were not penguins. Forster described the penguins as “black above, white below, with red bills & a red line extending towards the Eye... they all outstripped the Ship & went a head, but each Flock was soon replaced by a new numerous body coming up from astern & soon going a head, & this continued for more than a hour & a half”. He later named the penguin Aptenodytes Papua. It is nowadays known as the Gentoo Penguin (Pygoscelis papua).
Cook considered Resolution’s course, writing “we were only about 160 Leagues to the South of Tasmans track in 1642” and, “this space I expect Captain Furneaux will explore, who I expect is to the North of me”, which he was.
On 15 February, Cooper wrote, “Punish’d Wm Atkinson Seaman, Wm Briscoe Taylor, & Frans Taylor Marine 1 dozn each, also John Buttall Marine & Philip Brotherson Drummer ½ a dozen each for theft”. His description is a little confusing as William Briscoe was the ship’s tailor. Francis Taylor and John Buttall were privates in the Marines. Philip Brotherson was the drummer in the Marines. William Atkinson was an Able Seaman (AB). According to Gilbert, Atkinson was given only six lashes, not twelve.
Two days later, Cooper wrote, “Saw an Island of Ice to the NW. Bore away & stood for it... Hoisted out the large Cutter & Pinnace & employ’d them bringing on board the Small Ice about the Island”. Forster was impressed as “it was a most amazing high & bulky piece of Ice, full of cracks & crevices, which looked as blue as Ultramarine, the shades were all blueish, even to the very sumits”. Cooper added, “Served wine to the Ships Company instead of Grog”.
According to Cook, “Lights were seen in the Heavens similar to those seen in the Northern Hemisphere commonly known by name Aurora Borealis, or Northern Lights, but I never head of the Aurora Australis being seen before; the officer of the Watch [Clerke] observed that it sometimes broke out in spiral rays and in a circular form, then its light was very strong and its appearance beautifull”. The Southern Lights were seen again the following night.
On 21 February, Gilbert wrote, “Land suppos’d to be seen to the west... The supposed land prov’d to be nothing but clouds above the Horizon... Steer’d for an Island of Ice in order to get water... Brought too, hoisted out the Boats and sent them to take up Ice to Compleat our water from the small pieces which break off from the Islands”.
Two days later, Cook “passed this 24 hours 70 or 80 Islands of Ice many of them as large as any we have seen”. The next day “stood to the South till 8 pm at which time we were in the Latitude of 61° 52' S, the Ice Islands were now so numerous that we had passed upwards of Sixty or Seventy sence noon many of them a mile or a mile and a half in circuit... These obstacles together with dark nights and the advanced season of the year, discouraged me from carrying into execution a resolution I had taken of crossing the Antarctick Circle once more, according[ly] at 4 o’Clock in the AM we Tacked and Stood to the North”.
On 24 February, Cooper wrote, “Serv’d Grog to the Ship’s Company instead of wine”.
Four days later, on the last day of February, Forster wrote, “Some time ago our Goat had miscarried by a blow or fall she got in rolling weather & we lost two fine kids. Our Sow got the day before yesterday 9 pigs all of which perished the same day with cold, for we had not a handfull of Straw on board”.
On 3 March, “about noon” Cook “saw the Sun which we have not done for these 3 days past”. The next day, Forster noted “several white & brown Porpesses were about the Ship; one was struck but came off the Harpoon. The following day, Cook “passed only one Ice Island this 24 hours”.
On 6 March, Clerke wrote, “Captain Cook having Observ’d many of the People in rather a ragged condition, this forenoon he gave them some Needles thread and Buttons, that they may have no excuse for their tatter’d [condition] — they also have every Saturday to themselves to wash &c - that they may likewise have no excuse for a dirty, or improper appearance”. Midshipman Bowles Mitchel noted that the captain “examined their hands — those who had dirty, suffered the usual punishment (the daily allowance of grog stopped)”.
Fifteen Weeks at Sea Without Seeing Land
The following day, Mitchel noted “served the people (stopped yesterday) their usual allowance”. Forster realised “To morrow we are fifteen weeks out at Sea, without ever seeing Land; without other food than what we have on board, consisting in a few lean staring Sheep & Geese, the rest all salt-meat, & our best comfort a preservative Sour-Crout, never a Landbird, never a fresh fish comes to our table”. The next day, Cooper wrote, “Had the People’s Bedding up to Air & Clean’d between Decks”.
On 9 March, a gale caused Cook to consider the sailing qualities of Resolution. “By keeping about two or three points from the Wind she went at a great rate and altho we went in the through of the Sea, which as I have just observd run very high, we ship’d no Water to speake of, nor indeed has she done it at any other time. Upon the whole she goes as dry over the Sea as any ship I ever met with”. Forster’s comments in his journal were quite different. “Several Seas broke over the Quarterdeck, came down the Lather & between halfdecks, & as my Cabbin is just opposite I got water in it on more than one place”.
The next day, according to Clerke, “Fenton one of the Armourers Assistants fell from the Fore Cat-Harpens into the weather Fore Chains and wou’d have been overboard, but was caught with great presence of mind by Solomon Rarden one of the Boatswains Mates who happen’d to be walking the Fore Castle and saw him falling. He luckily reciev’d no material Hurt”. Thomas Fenton was saved by Solomon Reading. Cat harpins were used to tighten the shrouds (large ropes) of the lower masts behind their yards.
At noon on 14 March, Resolution was at latitude 58° 22' South. “The Weather became clear and pleasant”, wrote Cook, “and afforded us an oppertunity to make several observations of the Sun and Moon, the result of those made by Mr Wales (for I did not observe my self) reduced to Noon gave the Longitude 136° 32' E[ast]... [far south of Australia] Mr Kendalls Watch at the same time gave 134° 42' and that of Mr Arnolds gave the same, this is the first and only time they have pointed out the same Longitude sence we left England. The moderate and I might add pleasant weather we have had at times for these two or three days past made me wish I had been a few degrees of Latitude farther South... but we soon had Weather which convinced me that we were full far enough and that the time was approaching when these Seas were not to be navigated without induring intense cold”. William Wales, the astronomer, was responsible for the chronometers made by Larcum Kendall and John Arnold.
The next day, Forster explained, “We have been obliged to prepare a better & warmer birth for two Ewes & a Ram, which we wished to bring safe to New Zeeland, no more convenient place could be devised than the space between my & the Masters Cabin. I was now beset with cattle & stench on both Sides... My poor Cabin was often penetrated by the wet, & all the many chinks in it admitted the air & the cold from all sides freely”. He added, “the Capt throws hints out of staying all the winter in Queen Charlotte’s Sound”, New Zealand.
On 16 March, Cooper wrote, “Aurora Australis extremely bright & beautiful”. According to Cook “We continued to steer to the East inclining a little to the South till 5 o’Clock in the AM [of the 17th] at which time we... bore away NE and at Noon steer’d North inclining to the East with a resolution of making the best of my way to New Holland or New Zealand, my sole montive for wishing to make the former is to inform my self whether or no Van Diemens Land makes a part of that continent”.
Forster noted, “We have now several people that have some scorbutic symptoms, which prove a Scurvy that is gone pretty far, viz. bad Gums, livid Spots, Eruptions, difficult breathing, contracted limbs... but the Use of the Wort, to about 5 pints per day, & the bathing of the contracted limbs in wort & the Application of grains on them, has done very much towards mitigating & in some towards perfectly curing these Symptoms... The sower-crout has likewise, I believe, done very much towards keeping the people healthy & preventing the Scurvy; we are now more than 16 weeks at Sea & consequently is it no wonder, that some Symptoms of the Scurvy should appear”.
Two days later Cook decided that “As the Wind continued between the North and the West, [it] would not permit me to touch at Van Diemens Land, I shaped my Course for New Zealand”.
On 24 March, Forster “Saw more than 12 or 15 large common Albatrosses from brown to white, & all the intermediate hues: which great number of these birds proves our approaching to land & especially to warmer latitudes”.
Arrival at Dusky Bay / Dusky Sound, NZ
On 25 March, Cooper wrote, “This afternoon pass’d a deal of Weeds... Saw the Land ahead”. Gilbert wrote “Pass’d a Quantity of sea weed... Saw the Land at a great dist a head”.
The next day, Cook explained, “Intending to put into Dusky Bay or any other Port I could find on the Southern part of Newzealand, we steered in for the land”. Forster remarked, “We thought at first, that we were off dusky Bay... but upon a nearer Examination we found that we were to the South of Cape West & Dusky Bay, & had land before us, which they had not seen, when they sailed along the coast three years ago in Endeavour”. Resolution entered Dusky Bay, now called Dusky Sound, about noon, and anchored at the east end of Anchor Island. According to Cook, they had been “117 Days at Sea... without once having sight of land... As I did not like the place we had anchored in I sent Lieutt Pickersgill over to the SE side of the Bay to look for a more convenient Harbour while I went my self to the other side”. The next morning, Cook moved the ship, and “anchored in Mr Pickersgills Harbour... and moored her head and stern to the Trees”.
On 28 March, Cook wrote, “some of the officers went up the Bay in a small Boat on a shooting party, but returned again before noon and reported that they had seen Inhabitants”. Wales, having already found a place for an observatory, cleared “away the Ground; and I believe that before dinner I had cut down and destroyed more Trees & curious shrubs & Plants, than would in London have sold for one hundred Pounds”.
The next day, wrote Cook, “one small double Canoe in which were Eight of the natives appeared again and came within musquet shott of the Ship where they [were] looking at us for about half an hour or more and then retired”. In the afternoon, “Mr Forster with his party were out Botanizing”.
On 30 March, Cook “cleared places in the Woods near the Brook and set up Tents for the Water[er]s, Coopers, Sailmakers &ca”.
On the last day of March, Wales was “Still employed cutting down Trees, and erecting the Observatory”.
Ian Boreham
Originally published in Cook's Log, page 23, volume 46, number 1 (2023).